Concierge Care

How Longer Doctor Visits Can Change Preventive Care

Many of my patients ask whether longer doctor visits actually change anything, or whether extra time is just a nicer experience. It's a fair question, and I want to answer it honestly, even though I run a practice built around unhurried appointments.

The short answer is that more time may give you and your physician room for fuller conversations about your family history, your screening choices and your lifestyle goals. Research on what happens when primary care physicians are under less time pressure is still limited, though, and the findings are more mixed than you might expect 1. Time is one ingredient of good preventive care. It isn't the whole recipe.

Below I go through what the research shows, where extra time seems to matter most, and how to get the most from any visit, whatever kind of practice you use.

What research says about time pressure

Primary care physicians are under growing pressure to deliver complex care in short, fixed appointment slots. Earlier research has linked heavier time pressure to lower-quality care 1.

A recent study looked at the reverse question: what happens when a physician has a bit more breathing room? Researchers compared visits that came right before an unfilled same-day appointment slot (less time pressure) with visits that came before a filled slot. The study covered more than 190,000 primary care visits 1.

Under reduced time pressure, physicians:

  • Recorded slightly more diagnoses in total, and slightly more new diagnoses
  • Wrote a small number of additional new prescriptions
  • Ordered somewhat more diagnostic tests

There was no difference in referrals or in orders for preventive care, such as immunizations and routine health-maintenance items 1. The effect on diagnoses was largest for patients living with three or more chronic conditions. Separately, visits with a patient's usual physician included more orders for diagnostic testing and preventive care 1.

Two cautions apply. This was an observational (quasi-experimental) study from a single large health system, so it shows associations rather than proof of cause and effect. And the extra time in the study was modest. Still, it suggests that extra minutes alone may not automatically lead to more preventive care, and that seeing a physician who knows you may also matter.

Screening choices need conversation

Some screening decisions are simple. Others involve real trade-offs, and those are where unhurried time may help most.

For certain tests, guidance calls for shared decision making. That means you and your clinician weigh the possible benefits and harms together and choose based on the evidence and on what matters to you. For example, in one review of preventive care for men, prostate cancer screening with the PSA blood test in a defined age range is described as a decision to individualize through shared decision making 2.

These conversations take time, and busy clinics can find that hard. In a study of lung cancer screening in primary care, physicians generally shortened these discussions and handed the full conversation to a dedicated screening program. Most of them preferred referring patients to that program, partly because of time constraints 3.

Tools can also help. Patient decision aids are materials designed to support people facing health decisions. At a minimum, they make the decision explicit, give evidence-based information about the options and their benefits and harms, and help you clarify which features of each option matter most to you 4. A longer visit and a good decision aid can work together.

Family history and lifestyle goals

A good preventive visit starts with a thorough history. In a review of the adult well-male exam, the recommended focus includes tobacco and alcohol use, risk of sexually transmitted infections, and diet and exercise habits 2. Each of these can open a longer conversation than a short checklist allows.

In my practice, I find extra time most useful for the parts of a history that don't fit neatly into a form:

  • Family history: which relatives had which conditions, and how that may shape your own screening plan
  • Lifestyle goals: what you actually want to change, what has gotten in the way before, and what seems realistic
  • Questions about results: understanding what your numbers mean in context (see my post on abnormal lab results and reference ranges)

None of this requires a membership practice. It does need enough time and a relationship in which you feel comfortable raising what's on your mind. You can read more about my general approach on the wellness and prevention page.

Time is only one factor

It would be easy for a practice like mine to suggest that longer visits are the key to better health. The evidence doesn't support a claim that strong.

One economic study looked at physicians who switched to concierge medicine, a model in which the physician cares only for patients who pay a retainer fee. It found stronger evidence that patients were selected by income than by health. Among patients affected by the switch, it found large increases in spending and no average effect on mortality 5. That is a sobering result, and I think patients deserve to know it.

Other findings point to different factors that also matter:

  • Continuity: visits with your usual physician were associated with more preventive care orders 1
  • Systems and support: in lung cancer screening, approaches that pair primary care with a dedicated central program may improve how many people get screened and how well it's done 3
  • Different care models: direct primary care is one membership-style model the American Academy of Family Physicians has addressed in its policy 6, and house calls can be built into many kinds of family practices, from residency programs to direct primary care and concierge medicine 7

Good preventive care is possible in many settings. A well-organized traditional practice, a physician who knows you, and a health system with strong screening programs can each deliver it.

Making the most of any visit

However long your appointment is, a little preparation can make it more productive. The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality offers guidance on questions to ask your doctor 8, and MedlinePlus has practical resources on talking with your doctor 9 and on routine health checkups 10.

A few things you might bring:

  • A short list of your top questions, with the most important first
  • Notes on your family's health history, as far as you know it
  • A current list of your medicines and supplements
  • One or two health goals you'd like to discuss
  • Questions about any screening test you're unsure about, including its possible benefits and harms

If a screening decision feels rushed, it's reasonable to ask for a follow-up visit or written information so you can think it over.

Conclusion

Longer doctor visits may create room for fuller conversations about family history, screening trade-offs and personal goals, and that kind of conversation can make preventive care feel more like your own. The research is humbling, though. Reduced time pressure was associated with more diagnoses and tests but not with more preventive care orders 1, and switching to concierge care was not associated with lower average mortality 5.

In my view, what matters most is a physician who knows you, enough time to talk through decisions that need it, and a system that follows through. If you're curious how a membership practice works, my membership plans page explains the model. Many people also get excellent preventive care elsewhere. Whatever your setting, talk with your doctor about which screenings and goals make sense for you.

Frequently asked questions

Do concierge or membership practices lead to better health outcomes?

The evidence is limited. One study of physicians who switched to concierge medicine found large increases in spending and no average effect on mortality for affected patients 5. Longer visits may improve how care feels and how much gets discussed, but research hasn't shown that the model by itself improves survival.

What is shared decision making?

It's a process in which you and your clinician go over the options, including their possible benefits and harms, and choose together based on the evidence and your own values. It's commonly recommended for screening choices with real trade-offs, such as PSA testing for prostate cancer 2. Decision aids can support this process 4.

Can I get good preventive care in a traditional practice?

Yes. Good preventive care is possible in many settings. Seeing your usual physician has been associated with more preventive care orders 1, and preparing questions ahead of time can help any visit 89. Talk with your doctor about which screenings are right for you.

References

  1. Zhang L, Morgan KM, Cohen J, et al.. Provision of Primary Care Under Reduced Visit Time Pressures.. JAMA Intern Med. 2026. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42113503/
  2. Heidelbaugh JJ. The Adult Well-Male Examination.. Am Fam Physician. 2018. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30525354/
  3. Nguyen TD, Ezenwankwo E, Phan L, et al.. Process perspectives on lung cancer screening in primary care: a qualitative study of providers and staff in an urban U.S. healthcare system.. BMC Health Serv Res. 2026. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41781976/
  4. Stacey D, Lewis KB, Smith M, et al.. Decision aids for people facing health treatment or screening decisions.. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2024. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38284415/
  5. Leive A, David G, Candon M. On resource allocation in health care: The case of concierge medicine.. J Health Econ. 2023. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37329669/
  6. Direct Primary Care (AAFP policy). American Academy of Family Physicians. 2024. https://www.aafp.org/about/policies/direct-primary-care
  7. Rerucha CM, Salinas R Jr, Shook J, et al.. House Calls.. Am Fam Physician. 2020. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32803925/
  8. Questions To Ask Your Doctor. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (HHS). 2026. https://www.ahrq.gov/questions/index.html
  9. Talking With Your Doctor. MedlinePlus (National Library of Medicine, NIH). 2024. https://medlineplus.gov/talkingwithyourdoctor.html
  10. Health Checkup. MedlinePlus (National Library of Medicine, NIH). 2024. https://medlineplus.gov/healthcheckup.html

This article is for general education and is not medical advice. It does not create a doctor–patient relationship. Talk with your own physician before changing any medication, test schedule or treatment. If you think you are having a medical emergency, call 911.

← All posts